On Tuesday September 8, 2009, President Barack Obama will have a televised speech specifically for school aged children throughout the country. Reportedly the speech will "challenge students to work hard, set education goals, and take responsibility for their learning."
Many school districts in Utah will be notifying parents if their school decides to show it, and many will provide 'opt-out' activities for those children whose parents don't want their children exposed to such political rhetoric.
Really.
Have I gone down the rabbit hole? Do you remember the song in South Pacific called "You've Got to Be Carefully Taught"? Basically it is saying that fear, hate and prejudice must be taught. We aren't innately this way but grow that way from the influences around us that teach us.
I think as an American Society we are doing a HUGE disservice to our children. All the way from Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi and Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid down to inflammatory talk show hosts and conservative activists. We are carefully teaching our children that opposing ideas, no scratch that, opposing people are bad, evil, wrong. Is it so hard to believe that two people with opposing ideas can both love their country...so much that all they want is the best for it?
Apparently yes, and we see that example in our leaders, in Nancy Pelosi's thrilling autobiography she mentions a story about wanting to buy a house when her and her family first moved to California. Finding the perfect house with the perfect yard, in the perfect location, she asked the homeowner why they were moving. It turns out the family was moving to Washington D.C. to take a position in the Nixon administration. When she found out they were Republicans she decided she couldn't buy the house after all because there was no way she would live in a house a republican owned.
What were her children carefully taught? We have example after example on BOTH political extremes of hate being carefully taught.
Right wing author/columnist/commentator Ann Coulter has books out such as Treason: Liberal Treachery from the Cold War to the War on Terrorism or How to Talk to a Liberal (If You Must): The World According to Ann Coulter.
Obviously she has the right to speak her mind, but the approach she uses along with countless others is inflammatory, degrading and counterproductive to her position.
My question...what are we going to do to stop it? I am so tired of the arguments on both sides and frankly, the common phrase on both sides--'well the other side did it first' is just plain crap.
Are we back in Kindergarten? How about civil discourse. How about not jumping to conclusions. How about respect, Real respect. How about listening for a change before spouting off. How about teaching our children carefully. Carefully that all people have value. All people are children of a loving Heavenly Father. Carefully teaching them important truths that will guide them in making good and right decisions. Carefully teaching them that if you disagree with someone it doesn't make the other person a BAD person, it merely means they have a different opinion. Funny that we have been endowed by our creator with individual personalities and minds that DO NOT think the same. Do you think it chance? I don't. We have seen time and time again that growth comes from opposition. If we all agreed on every issue there would be no opposition. Without opposition there is no reason to progress, grow and become better.
I will be the First to admit that I am not President Obama's biggest fan. But darn it, I will NOT teach my children to hate him, to be disrespectful of him, or to diminish the office he legally and lawfully holds. Much of this furor was fueled by a Farmington Elementary showing a video about service to the kids. I don't agree with everything in the 'I Pledge' video. There are probably 5 or 6 phrases in that video that make me cringe. But darn it...there are another 3 minutes of pledging to do things that are right and good.
I pledge to find the good in opposing views and respectfully and carefully teach my children to treat all people with respect.
Thursday, September 3, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

6 comments:
About the speech.. I heard some of the opponents of the speech were saying that Obama was going to BRAINWASH their children.
UGH. How lame and disrespectful.
As I was reading your post, I was reminded of the intense exchange of ideas between Adams and Jefferson. They hammered out a lot of things and disagreed with each other, but in the end, had respect for each other.
We could learn from them, I suppose.
Well said Kat. I certainly don't mind my children hearing a message from our president. I respect the office and want my children to do as well.
I like that you brought up Ann Coulter. Everything that comes out of her mouth is so rude. It is frustrating because I agree with a lot of what she says, but not how she says it.
Dang...this was on good post! I need to remember to have Dave read this. He would enjoy it.
Found this quote earlier today:
My kind of loyalty was loyalty to one's country, not to its institutions or its office-holders. ~Mark Twain, A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court, 1889
I had seen a headline mentioning Obama's "Brainwashing" speech. To me it sounded like there are a lot of people out there with a great deal of fear. It's okay to be cautious and open-minded, but fearful and dis-respectful is not okay.
Still, like him or not, it could be problematic. No matter what you think and how you want to respond to what he says, your kids won't be with you when he speaks. They will be with their teachers and friends, so those will be the first opinions they hear, whether they love him or hate him.
I remember getting blasted with a teacher's opinion during school, and being too young at the time to be able to think it through. Heck, at the time I also thought everyone was Mormon and went to church every Sunday just like I did, not to mention political opinions.
I agree that he deserves respect. I agree that he will probably have some great things to say, even if the people that made up the accessory materials used some idiotic wording to describe the after activities. But I think the whole thing would would come across better if it was an evening broadcast when parents could watch it with their children and talk about it. Then together we could come up with our own way to "help the president."
Marni, you bring up some good points. As a parent you are letting a lot of control out of your hands when you send your kids to school period. (Good argument for homeschooling eh??) ;) The point about the teacher sharing opinions you don't agree with is valid. My neice had a teacher that was anti-hunting in 1st grade and she still doesn't eat meat to this day. (27 now) It is definitely a concern but a risk parents take if they send their kids to school. I think my beef with this issue is that people are automatically assuming that President Obama is out to indoctrinate kids with his 'evil' philosophies. Evil philosophies such as stay in school, work hard and be responsible for your own life. It is becoming tit for tat in politics where our children are being carefully taught to hate...hate others with differing opinions, wait not differeng opinions I mean who can argue with taking responsibility for ones actions. So just because a leader doesn't follow the same political thought as 'us' everything he says is tainted. (this goes for both sides of the spectrum) That is the feeling I get from these conservative groups that are protesting this. It was the same with ANYTHING President Bush said. And I find that very wrong. I wouldn't disagree that an evening speech when whole families could listen and discuss would be ideal. Do you remember the speech Pres. Reagan gave and his comments directed to the children? He said "And children, if your parents haven't been teaching you what it means to be an American, let 'em know and nail 'em on it. That would be a very American thing to do." This is taken from his farewell speech on Jan. 11 1989 you can read it here:http://www.reaganlibrary.net/ You'll have to scroll down a little to find the address. I'm just tired of both sides of the political spectrum trumpeting that their way is right and everyone else is evil. I think it would be very American to come together on what we do agree on and respectfully disagree and campaign where we differ. I think that is very different than what is going on now. I feel like there is so much pride involved in people’s positions that even though Americans probably agree on things 70% of the time we can’t admit it because of the other 30%. How are we to ever be the United States?
Post a Comment